The Colts Best & Fairest has found a home at Southerners on 20 occasions, with Imperials seeing the medal awarded to a Magpie 15 times.
We thank East Perth Football Club for their support of the LSWFL Colts Competition and the Best & Fairest Medal, along with Talison Lithium for their support of the Runner Up trophy.
| Year | Winner | Club | Runner Up | Club |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1961 | N. Reeve | Deanmill | ||
| 1962 | ||||
| 1963 | ||||
| 1964 | G. Flanagan | Southerners | ||
| 1965 | J. Timms | Southerners | ||
| 1966 | N. Buss | Imperials | ||
| 1967 | J. Trainos | Tigers | ||
| 1968 | T. Reeve | Deanmill | ||
| 1969 | L. Hunt | Imperials | ||
| 1970 | B. Battilana | Imperials | ||
| 1971 | S. Ditri | Southerners | ||
| 1972 | ||||
| 1973 | R. De Campo | Southerners | ||
| 1974 | K. O’Connor | Bridgetown | ||
| 1975 | S. De Campo | Southerners | ||
| 1976 | P. Towie | Imperials | ||
| 1977 | J. Spiroff | Deanmill | ||
| 1978 | R. Germanste | Southerners | ||
| 1979 | S. Collins | Deanmill | ||
| 1980 | Pietr Stubberfield | Imperials | ||
| 1981 | Donald Milentis | Imperials | ||
| 1982 | George Giannakis | Imperials | ||
| 1983 | Gary Ryan | Imperials | ||
| 1984 | Nigel Reeve | Deanmill | ||
| 1985 | Brendan Barnsby | Southerners | ||
| 1986 | Alan Rogers | Southerners | ||
| 1987 | Renaldo Galos | Tigers | ||
| 1988 | Rodney Court | Southerners | ||
| 1989 | Darren Stemp | Deanmill | ||
| 1990 | Jeff Nixon | Southerners | ||
| 1991 | Gary Williams | Southerners | ||
| 1992 | Tom Forman | Southerners | ||
| 1993 | Jade Hurrell | Bridgetown | ||
| 1994 | Andrew Tuthill | Deanmill | ||
| 1995 | Damian Waugh | Imperials | ||
| 1996 | Ryan Hughes | Southerners | ||
| 1997 | Joshua Rayson | Bridgetown | D. Blechynden | Bridgetown |
| 1998 | Mark Dronow | Imperials | S. Jonker | Imperials |
| S. Ellis | Bridgetown | |||
| 1999 | Rodney Mathews | Imperials | D. French | Southerners |
| 2000 | Aaron East | Tigers | D. Magenta | Bridgetown |
| 2001 | Chris Rickman | Southerners | R. Bachos | Tigers |
| 2002 | Nick Kitis | Deanmill | R. Bachos | Tigers |
| 2003 | Cameron Morris | Southerners | B. Gandy | Imperials |
| Brandt Pears | Deanmill | |||
| 2004 | Michael Bachos | Tigers | J. Franceschi | Southerners |
| 2005 | Josh Franceschi | Southerners | P. Samsa | Bridgetown |
| 2006 | Daniel Riley | Imperials | J. Miolin | Tigers |
| 2007 | T. Fisher | Bridgetown | B. Conopo | Imperials |
| 2008 | J. Rudd | Southerners | T. Auvache | Deanmill |
| 2009 | Daniel Schrama | Bridgetown | A. Bennell | Imperials |
| 2010 | Keenan Wilson | Imperials | J. Ioannou | Deanmill |
| 2011 | Lee Lucev | Kojonup | A. Wallam | Kojonup |
| 2012 | Ashley Wallam | Kojonup | J. Reeve | Deanmill |
| 2013 | Connor McRae | Southerners | M. Wheatley | Bridgetown |
| 2014 | Samual Tiszavolgy | Tigers | E. Christophis | Deanmill |
| 2015 | Mitchell De Campo | Southerners | K. Wilson | Bridgetown |
| 2016 | Joshua De Campo | Deanmill | K. Donohue | Tigers |
| Jack Richards | Bridgetown | Ronan Phillips-Johns | Imperials | |
| 2017 | Zane Russo | Tigers | Joshua De Campo | Deanmill |
| 2018 | Timothy Davies | Bridgetown | Kye Jasper | Southerners |
| 2019 | Heath Bernadin | Imperials | J. Edwards | Tigers |
| 2020 | – – | |||
| 2021 | Zachary Hall | Imperials | Brock Tempra | Deanmill |
| 2022 | Tobi Gunson | Tigers | Memphis Mayers | Imperials |
| 2023 | Jed Edwards | Tigers | Brody Taylor | Imperials |
| Tyson Jacobs | Southerners | |||
| 2024 | Hamish Omodei | Southerners | Conor Cole | Tigers |
