Of the 65 League Best & Fairest awards presented, there have been several multi time winners, with John Turner racking up a remarkable 7 for Southerners between 1963 and 1973.
We thank Tyrepower Manjimup for their support of the LSWFL League Competition and the Tyrepower Medal, along with Johnson’s Food Services for their support of the Runner Up trophy.
| Year | Winner | Club | Runner Up | Club |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1959 | E. Gartner | Royals | ||
| 1960 | Ray Lucev | Tigers | ||
| 1961 | Charlie Walker | Tigers | ||
| 1962 | John Turner | Southerners | ||
| 1963 | ||||
| 1964 | John Turner | Southerners | ||
| 1965 | John Turner | Southerners | ||
| 1966 | Harvey Giblett | Deanmill | ||
| 1967 | Ray Prentice | Imperials | ||
| 1968 | John Turner | Southerners | ||
| 1969 | John Brearley | Deanmill | ||
| 1970 | Neil Sherwood | Boyup Brook | ||
| 1971 | John Turner | Southerners | ||
| 1972 | John Turner | Southerners | ||
| 1973 | John Turner | Southerners | M. Worth | Bridgetown |
| 1974 | Eric Moltoni | Southerners | C. Hannah | Imperials |
| 1975 | Danny Blechynden | Tigers | ||
| 1976 | Clint Hannah | Imperials | D. Blechynden | Tigers |
| Michael Spiroff | Deanmill | |||
| 1977 | John Alcock | Bridgetown | N. Radcliffe | Boyup Brook |
| 1978 | Orest Luzny | Southerners | G. Mead | Boyup Brook |
| D. Blechynden | Tigers | |||
| R. Lee | ||||
| 1979 | Kevin Mead | Boyup Brook | R. DeCampo | Southerners |
| 1980 | David Booth | Tigers | R. DeCampo | Southerners |
| 1981 | Ian Fox | Imperials | G. Becket | Boyup Brook |
| Trevor Collins | Deanmill | |||
| 1982 | Ian Fox | Imperials | D. Blechynden | Tigers |
| R. Marinoni | ||||
| 1983 | Richie Lee | Imperials | J. Sebire | Southerners |
| 1984 | Leigh Wright | Tigers | D. Martyn | Southerners |
| 1985 | Charlie Staite | Tigers | V. Peos | Deanmill |
| 1986 | Alan Casserlley | Boyup Brook | D. Martyn | Southerners |
| 1987 | Peter Adams | Deanmill | R. Masters | Imperials |
| 1988 | Michael Staples | Southerners | B. Froome | Deanmill |
| 1989 | Steven Bogar | Boyup Brook | G. Little | Boyup Brook |
| 1990 | Heath East | Deanmill | S. Bogar | Boyup Brook |
| J. Walker | Tigers | |||
| 1991 | Todd East | Deanmill | B. Hickman | Imperials |
| 1992 | Ray Masters | Imperials | M. Armstrong | Imperials |
| 1993 | Ray Masters | Imperials | J. Craig | Tigers |
| 1994 | Brad Ellis | Southerners | D. Moloney | Deanmill |
| 1995 | James Craig | Tigers | H. East | Deanmill |
| 1996 | Heath East | Deanmill | M. Armstrong | Imperials |
| 1997 | Heath East | Deanmill | M. Wallace | Boyup Brook |
| 1998 | Ben Doyle | Imperials | M. Wallace | Boyup Brook |
| 1999 | Michael Evans | Boyup Brook | S. Young | Boyup Brook |
| 2000 | Lloyd Haskett | Boyup Brook | T. Della Franca | Southerners |
| 2001 | Heath East | Deanmill | S. Young | Boyup Brook |
| 2002 | Michael Crain | Bridgetown | H. East | Deanmill |
| 2003 | Michael Crain | Bridgetown | H. East | Deanmill |
| 2004 | Scott Roche | Southerners | P. Reyne | Bridgetown |
| 2005 | Shayne Martin | Southerners | R. Carr | Tigers |
| 2006 | Tristan Mead | Boyup Brook | Brett Fraser | Tigers |
| 2007 | Davron Franklin | Imperials | John McGinty | Deanmill |
| 2008 | Tyson Lee | Imperials | Brett Fraser | Tigers |
| John McGinty | Deanmill | |||
| 2009 | Keegan Bennett | Deanmill | T. Greney | Boyup Brook |
| Tim Ioannou | Deanmill | |||
| Tyson Lee | Imperials | |||
| 2010 | Brett Fraser | Tigers | Tim Ioannou | Deanmill |
| 2011 | Hayden McLeod | Boyup Brook | Tim Lyster | Southerners |
| 2012 | Toby Lloyd | Boyup Brook | Thomas Treloar | Bridgetown |
| 2013 | Tim Lyster | Southerners | Paul Starkie | Tigers |
| 2014 | David Winter | Boyup Brook | Paul Starkie | Tigers |
| 2015 | Mathew Harbeck | Imperials | Luke Doyle | Tigers |
| Michael Robinson | Southerners | |||
| 2016 | Brett Wilson | Bridgetown | Daniel McGinlay | Imperials |
| 2017 | Michael Robinson | Southerners | David Roche | Southerners |
| 2018 | Jack Bridgland | Bridgetown | Jeffrey Smith | Tigers |
| 2019 | Hugh Mitchell | Bridgetown | Ben Thompson | Boyup Brook |
| 2020 | ||||
| 2021 | Mckenzi Nix | Boyup Brook | Brendon White | Bridgetown |
| 2022 | Hugh Mitchell | Bridgetown | Jaxon East | Deanmill |
| 2023 | David Cowan | Bridgetown | Matt Marinoni | Kojonup |
| 2024 | David Cowan | Boyup Brook | Brett Wilson | Bridgetown |
